3 Days of Extreme Survival in Scotland: Can Two Beginners Survive?

By Steven Kelly (Survival Ste)

Two participants, three days and two nights in the woods. Jordan and David came to Ayrshire in Scotland with limited survival experience, and we set them a series of challenges to see how they would cope with the basics of wilderness survival.

Jamie Frizzell organised the extreme survival experience, while Sam Mouzer, Danny P and I supported the event with safety and logistics. Rather than doing everything for the participants, the idea was to get them thinking, working together and putting practical skills to the test.

Watch the three-day extreme survival challenge

Watch the full Ayrshire extreme survival challenge on YouTube.

Building a shelter in the Scottish woods

The first job for Jordan and David was to build a lean-to shelter. Shelter is one of the most important skills in a British survival situation. It is not just somewhere to sleep. It is about protecting yourself from the weather, reducing heat loss and giving yourself a base from which to work.

When you're spending two nights in the woods, the decisions you make about shelter on the first day can make a big difference to the rest of your experience. Building something functional with natural materials takes planning, patience and teamwork.

Challenge one: starting a fire with limited equipment

We gave the lads a block of birch, a knife and a ferro rod. Their task was to get a fire going.

It sounds straightforward, but having a ferro rod does not guarantee a fire. You have to understand how to prepare suitable tinder and fuel, and how to manage the early stages of a fire without smothering it.

I've spent years teaching fire lighting, and it is one of those skills where practice matters far more than watching somebody else do it.

Challenge two: boiling water without a metal pot

For the next challenge, Jordan and David had to boil water in a paper cup and a plastic bottle. The exercise was designed to get them thinking about improvisation and how to solve a problem when conventional equipment is unavailable.

These were supervised challenge exercises, not recommended methods for making drinking water safe. In a real situation, use a suitable cooking vessel and an appropriate water treatment method; heating plastic can release unwanted chemicals and boiling alone does not remove chemical contamination.

Challenge three: building a survival trap

The final challenge was to construct a trap. If it met the standard, we would give the participants a pigeon for food.

This was a practical assessment, not a requirement to catch a live animal. The emphasis was on problem-solving, understanding how a mechanism works and paying attention to detail. Any real-world trapping must comply with wildlife legislation and animal welfare requirements.

What three days in the woods can teach you

After 23 years in the British Army, including service with 29 Commando Regiment Royal Artillery, and completing 56 days across Naked and Afraid and Naked and Afraid: Apocalypse, I've learnt that survival isn't about having the most expensive kit or knowing the most impressive tricks.

It is about getting the fundamentals right. Prioritise what matters, stay calm when things don't go to plan and keep working the problem.

For beginners, there is real value in spending time outdoors under the supervision of experienced instructors. It gives people an opportunity to develop their confidence and discover which skills they need to practise before relying on them in a genuine emergency.

A big thanks to Jamie for organising the experience, to Sam and Danny for keeping things running, and to Jordan and David for getting stuck in.

More survival adventures and training

If you enjoyed seeing us back together in Scotland, watch Highland Reckoning, my independently produced survival series with Jamie Frizzell and Sam Mouzer.

If you want to develop your own practical wilderness skills, take a look at the survival and bushcraft training we deliver at South West Survival in Devon.

For television, presenting and media opportunities, find out more about my work as a British TV survival expert.

Could you spend three days and two nights in the woods? Watch the video and let me know in the comments which challenge you would find the hardest.

FREE FIELD GUIDE

7 Skills That Kept Me Alive on Naked and Afraid

Get the free guide, plus new journal posts and podcast episodes when they drop. Written by me, not an algorithm.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time.

Jordan and David during the three-day extreme survival challenge in Ayrshire, ScotlandJordan and David during the three-day extreme survival challenge in Ayrshire, ScotlandJordan and David during the three-day extreme survival challenge in Ayrshire, Scotland